Project 5

Development and evaluation of transgenic virus resistant tomato plants for crop production in subtropical and tropical areas

Content:

Aims Phase I

Interim Report Phase I
   - Studies on viruses in
     Thailand
   - RNA-mediated
      resistance

Aims and planned studies Phase II


Publications


Scientists:

Prof. E. Maiss
D. Knierim
S. Attathom

last update:
january 2008


Aims Phase I

Transgenic tomato plants conferring resistance to Tomato mosaic virus (ToMV), Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) and Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) will be produced. For this purpose RNA-mediated-resistance and protein-mediated-resistance strategies will be applied. To establish RNA-mediated-resistance, non-translatable fragments of viral genomes will be expressed in tomato plants. For generation of protein-mediated-resistance, inhibitory peptides identified from a phage-display-library, will be introduced into plants. An advantage of using only short genomic viral fragments in transgenic plants is the reduction of the likelihood for the generation of altered viruses due to possible recombination events. In a second strategy the potential of protein-mediated resistance will be elucidated. A phage-display library, expressing peptides, is screened for the presence of biologically active molecules interfering with virus infection in vitro. The corresponding sequences of peptides will be subsequently cloned and expressed in plants to verify their potential of virus suppression in vivo. The concept of transgenic virus resistant plants in the frame of IPM will be addressed in close co-operation with project 1.


Back to main page


Interim Report Phase I


Studies on viruses in Thailand

During the experiments in Thailand viruses were recognized in the greenhouses by heavy symptom expression in infected tomato plants (see figure 1). The symptoms indicated the presence of Tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV) and a Tospovirus e.g. Tomato spotted wilt virus and/or Groundnut bud necrosis virus (GBNV, synonym Peanut bud necrosis virus).

Fig. 1.: Symptoms of a Tospovirus affecting tomato fruits and leaves

Serological tests confirmed TYLCV infections (Antiserum: DSMZ AS-0546/2) and the presence of a Tospovirus belonging to serogroup IV (Antiserum: Agdia SRA 61500/0500 for GBNV and Watermelon silver mottle virus; WSMV).
To get more detailed information about TYLCV (named TYLCV-AIT) and the Tospovirus affecting the tomatoes in the AIT greenhouses further molecular characterisations were done.

Using TYLCV specific primers fragments of the TYLCV-AIT named virus were amplified. The entire nucleotide sequence of component A of TYLCV-AIT comprises of 2747 nts. A nucleotide BLAST at GenBank (NCBI) reveals 94% sequence homology to the TYLCV-Thailand segment A DNA (Accession: X63015). Also the phylogenetic tree reveals a clear position of TYLCV-AIT in the cluster of other TYLCV isolates from Thailand.

In addition PCR fragments were generated, using different primers designed according to sequences of Tospoviruses from GenBank. Approximately 1100 nts of a S-RNA sequence containing the complete 3`terminus, an entire N-gene and a part of an intergenic region were determined. The alignment of the new N-gene amino acid sequence with described viruses of the tospovirus serogroup IV reveals the highest identity with Capsicum chlorosis virus (CCV, Accession: AY036058). However, the alignment of the intergenic region of about 270 bp, starting from the end of the N-gene sequence, shows a greater distance to CCV. Because of these differences and further descriptions of the biology of this virus (Chiemsombat, pers. communication) the name Tomato necrotic spot virus (TNSV) is proposed.

RNA-mediated resistance

Transformation cassettes were established according to sequence information gathered from analysis of PCR fragments generated from Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV), Tomato mosaic virus (ToMV) and Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV). To minimize putative risks of virus resistant transgenic plants, only a part of each coat protein (CP) gene or the N-gene, respectively, was used as a non translatable form and without the 3`termini. For CMV and ToMV the core region of the CP was chosen, for TSWV the core region of the N-gene was selected. All the cassettes were constructed as inverted repeats separated by an intron. The entire construct was assembled under control of an enhanced 35S Cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) promoter. Four different cassettes were transformed. For each of the viruses a single construct consisting only of an enhanced 35S promoter, an inverted repeat of the viral sequence separated by an intron and terminated by a termination signal of CaMV was cloned. In addition a triple construct with all three virus sequences in the order TSWV, CMV and ToMV was created. As binary transformation vectors pGreen0229 and pLX222 (bar-gene respectively nptII-gene as selection marker) were chosen.

Transformation with the binary vectors containing the different cassettes was done with Nicotiana benthamiana as a model plant to check the suitability of the constructs in conferring resistance. The resistance tests were done on the T1 generation. For this purpose the seeds of each regenerated line were harvested.
Each resistance test was done with 15 plants per line. Visual inspection and recoding of symptoms starts 7-10 dpi. For comparison 15 non transgenic N. benthamiana plants act as control plants. The lines containing the single cassettes were tested with the corresponding virus. For transgenic lines containing the triple constructs, 15 plants each were separately inoculated with each virus. Not all lines have been tested so far for resistance. The single inverted repeat constructs confer resistance to TSWV, CMV and ToMV. Several plants of the tested lines show either a delay in symptom expression or reacted immune, without any visible symptoms. No plants were observed with a recovery type of resistance. Unfortunately the construct consisting of an inverted repeat of all three viruses confers resistance only to TSWV in 3 lines but none of the lines was also resistant to CMV and ToMV.


Back to content


Aims and planned studies Phase II


RNA-mediated virus resistance will be established against Tomato necrotic spot virus (TNSV) and Tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV) in tobacco and tomato. The aim is to generate multiple virus resistance against both viruses within only one transformation step. For this purpose transformation vectors will be constructed with inverted-repeat cassettes of both viruses. These constructs will be transformed with Agrobacterium-mediated gene transfer into N. benthamiana and Lycopersicum esculentum. The proof of principle will be checked with transgenic N. benthamiana plants. Tomatoes will be transformed in close co-operation with the project partner in Thailand. The plants will also be investigated within project P1 to evaluate the performance under conditions of IPM.
TNSV is the prevalent virus occurring in Thailand. The complete sequences of L-, M- and S-RNA will be determined. Comparisons of N-genes from different TNSV will indicate the diversity of the virus. Molecular data taken together with data concerning vector transmission and virus-host interaction will allow a definite characterisation of this tospovirus within serogroup IV of the tospoviruses.


Back to content


Publications


D. Knierim and E. Maiss
Application of Phi29 DNA polymerase in identification and full-length clone inoculation of Tomato yellow leaf curl Thailand virus and Tobacco leaf curl Thailand virus

ABSTRACT
Tomato plants grown in greenhouses in Thailand developed typical symptoms of a Tomato yellow leaf curl Thailand virus (TYLCTHV) infection. After confirmation by ELISA a Phi29 DNA polymerase approach was chosen for further molecular analysis of TYLCTHV. Total DNA purified from infected tomato leaves was subjected to rolling circle amplification (RCA) of DNA-A and DNA-B of TYLCVTHV. In addition, a new monopartite geminivirus with a putative recombinant background was identified by RCA and tentatively named Tobacco leaf curl Thailand virus (TbLCTHV). To confirm the composition of both geminiviruses full-length clones were established and used for inoculation of Nicotiana benthamiana by particle bombardment or agroinfection. When TYLCTHV DNA-A and DNA-B were applied together by particle bombardment or agroinfection severe stunting, yellowing and leaf curling was observed. Whereas TYLCTHV DNA-A and TbLCTHV revealed no infection after particle bombardment, similar symptoms in N. benthamiana like leaf upward curling and yellowing were observed following agroinfection. DNA components of TYLCTHV DNA-A and DNA-B were excised from respective plasmids, ligated and amplified by Phi29 DNA polymerase. The ability of viral concatamere inoculation was evaluated in particle co-bombardment experiments on N. benthamiana. Thus, particle bombardment of RCA derived multimeric products proved to be at least as effective as inoculation with a partial repeat construct and tenfold as effective as inoculation with excised unit-lengths of DNA-A and DNA-B of TYLCVTHV when using each DNA component in an amount of 5 ng.



D. Knierim, R. Blawid, and E. Maiss
The complete nucleotide sequence of a capsicum chlorosis virus isolate from Lycopersicum esculentum in Thailand

ABSTRACT
The complete nucleotide sequence of a tospovirus isolated from Lycopersicum esculentum in Thailand was determined. The L RNA comprises of 8912 nt and codes for the RNA-dependent RNA-polymerase (RdRp) (2877 aa). Two ORFs are located on theMRNA(4823 nt) encoding the non-structural (NSm) protein (308 aa) and the viral glycoprotein precursors (Gn/Gc) (1121 aa) separated by an intergenic region of 433 nt. ORFs coding for the non-structural (NSs) and nucleocapsid (N) protein, 439 aa and 275 aa, respectively, were identified on the S RNA (3477 nt) separated by an intergenic region of 1202 nt. The N protein of the Thailand isolate was most closely related to that of capsicum chlorosis virus (CaCV), sharing an amino acid sequence identity of 92.7%. Additionally, multiple sequence analyses revealed significant similarities to tospoviruses of the species Watermelon silver mottle virus and to several putative tospovirus entries in GenBank. Based on these alignments it is proposed to refer to all these different viruses as isolates of CaCV.



W. T. S. D. Premachandra, C. Borgemeister, E. Maiss, D. Knierim, and H.-M. Poehling (2005).
Ceratothripoides claratris, a New Vector of a Capsicum chlorosis virus Isolate Infecting Tomato in Thailand
Phytopathology, 2005, Vol. 95, No. 6, 659-663.

ABSTRACT
Ceratothripoides claratris, the predominant thrips species on tomato in Thailand, was tested for vector competence and efficiency to transmit Capsicum chlorosis virus (CaCV) (isolate AIT) to tomato. The efficiency of adult-stage transmission was influenced by the larval stage at which virus was acquired. Adult C. claratris showed 69% transmission efficiency after acquiring the virus as freshly emerged (<1 h) first-instar larvae. However, when just molted (<1 h) second-instar larvae acquired the virus, the percentage of adult transmitters significantly decreased (48%). Transmission efficiency of up to 47% was detected with second-instar larvae of C. claratris which had acquired the virus as freshly emerged first-instar larvae. Transmission efficiency did not significantly differ between adult males and females, irrespective of the larval stage at which the virus was acquired. Highest transmission efficiency for CaCV was recorded in adult C. claratris derived from second-instar larvae collected from infected tomato plants in a greenhouse. Lowest transmission efficiency was observed in adults directly collected from infected tomato plants in the greenhouse. The spread of CaCV on tomato plants in greenhouses showed a close association with thrips infestations.




Back to content