Project 1

Integrated management of tomato pests with special emphasis on biological control of thrips

Content:

Aims Phase I

Interim Report Phase I
   - Central experiment
   - Studies on thrips
   - Studies on leafminers
   - Studies on white flies
   - Cooperative studies

Aims and planned studies Phase II


Publications


Scientists:

Prof. H.-M. Poehling
Prof. B. Napompeth
Prof. T. Attathom
A. Upanisakorn
N. Halaweh
N. Nguyen

retired colleagues:
P. Kumar
(finished his PhD)
M. B. Hossain
(finished his PhD)
S. Dieball
Dr. T. Achilles
(finished)
Dr. D. Premachandra
(finished her PhD)
Prof. C. Borgemeister
(now: Director General of the
International Centre of Insect Physiology and Ecology (ICIPE)
P.O. Box 30772-00100
Nairobi, Kenya )

last update:
January 2009


Aims Phase I

In sub-project 1 of Project 1 we intend to research possibilities for biological and integrated control of pests (i.e. various Lepidoptera, white flies, aphids, thrips) in tomato crops in Thailand. Primarily we want to use protected cultivation techniques (i.e. net-houses with plastic roofs) to influence the dispersion and host-finding behaviour of pests, and to investigate possibilities for inundative releases of natural enemies (as commonly applied in temperate zones). Moreover we will test the efficacy of selected pesticides (e.g. Bt and neem). These control options need to be adapted, combined and finally integrated into a holistic integrated production system for tomatoes under protected cultivation within the framework of a collaborative 'Central Experiment' (CE), in which all sub-projects will participate. In sub-project 2 we intend to investigate more fundamental aspects of the population dynamics of thrips and try to develop new strategies for biological control of thrips. The latter will include research on the impact of parasitoids of foliage-feeding life stages of the thrips, and application of predatory mites and entomopathogenic nematodes and fungi against soil-dwelling life stages of the thrips. Joint research activities will include optimising biological control techniques to reduce the vector potential of thrips (together with Project 5). As our principal collaborator in Thailand Dr. Banpot Napompeth of the National Biological Control Research Center (NBCRC) will be in charge of the selection, mass production and tests on efficacy of parasitoids and predators of white flies, aphids and thrips.



















Back to main page


Interim Report Phase I


Central experiment:
Results from the continuously running central experiment clearly show that greenhouse with open side walls for ventilation are not suitable for tomato production under the conditions in Thailand. Even high input of insecticides did not prevent heavy infections of thrips- and white fly-transmitted viral diseases. Net houses equipped with 40 mesh cover considerably reduce infestation levels by white flies, and a 78 mesh cover can substantially reduce invasions by thrips. However, white fly and thrips infestations can not be fully excluded, e.g. by workers and researchers entering the GHs. Apart from white flies and thrips, other insect pests are no real threat for tomatoes under protected cultivation in the greater Bangkok area.

Studies on thrips:
> The predominant thrips species on tomatoes in the greater Bangkok area was always Ceratothripoides claratris (Shumsher) . Hence, all further experiments focused on C. claratris. First studies on basic biology were performed. Major findings were short development time and high fecundity of C. claratris at high temperatures. Moreover, at higher temperatures C. claratris has a significantly biased female sex ratio and a relatively long life span. The high reproductive potential and the short life cycle at high temperatures can lead to rapid population build-up of C. claratris. Optimum temperature for C. claratris is 30-33°C, closely matching the prevailing conditions in our greenhouses at AIT, and thus stressing the high pest potential of C. claratris under the hot and humid conditions in central Thailand. Host plant preference studies revealed that the thrips heavily attacked and successfully reproduced on cucumber, pumpkin, cowpea, yard long bean and chilli. C. claratris, caused direct damage and acts as virus vector. In close cooperation with P5 we identified a serogroup IV tospovirus which strongly effects plant health. Results of the molecular characterisation of the virus in Hannover to date suggest that the pathogen is most likely Tomato Necrotic Spot Virus (TNSV) (for details see report P5).
Population dynamics studies showed that C. claratris infestation initiated from the border rows at the side walls of the greenhouse. Possibly the air stream produced by the ventilation fan of the opposite greenhouse pushed thrips through the gauze, leading to thrips hot spots in this part of the greenhouse. Most often thrips infestation started to develop from the lower leaves of the tomato plants and gradually spread upwards with time.
First efforts to control thrips inside the greenhouses focused on “biopesticides” (Neem, Spinosad). In a parallel study at IPP, G. Thoeming studied systemic effects of Neem on different life-stages of western flower thrips Frankliniella occidentalis (Thoeming et al., 2003). They could show in laboratory and semi-field tests, that soil applications of Neem can efficiently control F. occidentalis. The effect of a soil application of NeemAzal MD (5% Azadirachtin), on the survival of L1, L2 and the adults of C. claratris was assessed. Major findings were low mortality of L2 and adults at all the dose rates tested following a soil application. However, survival of L1 was greatly affected by NeemAzal MD. In addition Neem had direct contact toxicity and high residual effects but only with first larval stage. Spinosad, proved to be highly toxic to most developmental stages of C. claratris causing almost always 100% mortality. Only a direct ovicidal activity was not observed .

Studies on leafminers:
Liriomyza sativae Blanchard was identified as the main leaf miner species. The polyphagous species is not only a pest of tomatoes. This was shown by a field experiments measuring the infestation and development on three different vegetable species. Best performance was on cucumber but with heavy attacks of tomatoes and watermelons too. Results from the CE with comparison of infestation in open and closed greenhouses clearly indicate that net barriers can completely inhibit the immigration of adult leaf miners. The main part of the study so far focused on the use of Neem compounds to control leaf miners. It could be shown that Neem is very efficient. If applied to infested leaves, larval stages inside suffer high mortality. Similar high levels of efficiency occurs if Neem is applied to the soil. Obviously the active compounds are not only translocated translaminar but also systemically by root uptake acropetal.

Studies on white flies:
The white fly (WF) Bemisia tabaci Gennadius, is one of the major constraints for tomato production in this area, especially because of high disease pressure of WF-transmitted Tomato Yellow Leaf Curl Virus (TYLCV). Equipping GHs with 40 mesh covers for the side walls could substantially reduce the WF pressure and the prevalence of TYLCV infections. Further results indicate that systemic Neem applications can provide tomato plants for up 96 h post treatment with sufficient levels of protection against B. tabaci. Strongest effects of systemic Neem treatments were recorded in terms of immature mortality and on the emergence of the F1. Effects on colonisation behaviour, egg laying and egg hatchability were less pronounced. Seed treatment resulted in reduction of oviposition and very high mortality in immature WF, with levels up to 80% at the highest Neem concentration. More striking were even the (long-term) effects on the emergence in F1. Here at the highest dose rate emergence of the F1 was reduced by more than 80%. Likewise, treating tomato seeds with Neem enabled the plants to withstand for considerable periods a WF infestation. In the forthcoming CE we will integrate Neem treatments into our regular nursery protocol.

Cooperative studies:
In studies in cooperation with Prof. Tipvadee Attathom (Kasetsart University) specific DNA markers were evaluated for molecular characterisation of white fly biotypes and the potential of naturally occurring entomopathogenic fungi for thrips control was evaluated.


Back to content


Aims and planned studies Phase II


One of the main results of the first phase of this project was the discovery that thrips, especially C. claratris, are the predominant pests of tomatoes under protected cultivation in the greater Bangkok area, and the fact that C. clartris is apparently vectoring a yet to be identified Tospovirus (possibly TNSV – see P5). Hence in the second phase its vector activity, and interactions between the plant, the virus and these vector will be studied. Moreover, we want to investigatethe sources for the virus infection, which stages of the vector can successfully obtain and subsequently transmit the pathogen, and which time the vector requires for acquiring, internal processing and transmission of the virus. Additionally, we will investigate the time required for symptom development in infected plants, and whether a virus infection causes physiological changes both in the plant as well as the vector. The latter is particularly important for possible effects on the dispersion of the virus, i.e. for the epidemiology of the disease. Building on the ongoing work on genetic characterisation of B. tabaci strains, in an additional cooperative project with Prof. T. Attathom/KU we want to study the genetic diversity of C. claratris populations on tomatoes in Thailand by analysing the ITS region of ribosomal DNA by means of RFLP. These studies will be addressed in part I.

In part II of this project we intend to develop environmentally friendly vector control strategies. Based on our experiences with physical exclusion of arthropod pests in GH using nets with different mesh sizes we additionally seek to investigate behaviour-modifying UV-absorbing plastic sheets and reflecting mulches with the aim to disrupt the immigration and plant colonisation by thrips and we want to evaluate the efficacy of thrips natural enemies, i.e. entomopathogenic fungi and nematodes as well as arthropod predators including studies on the potential side effects of UV-absorbing plastic sheets and reflecting mulches as well as entomopathogens on beneficial organisms. Part of these investigations will be carried out in close collaboration with Prof. T. Attathom/KU (entomopathogenic fungi/side effects of entomopathogens) and Dr. V. Somsook/DoA (entomopathogenic nematodes).

After finding individual solutions in satellite experiments these will be continuously integrated and tested in the CE.


Back to content


Publications


Nguyen, T.H.N., Borgemeister,C., Max, J., Poehling; H.M.(2009)
Manipulation of ultraviolet light affects immigration behaviour of Ceratothripoides claratris.
Journal of Economic Entomology, (accepted)


ABSTRACT
Studies were conducted in tropical greenhouses to elucidate the role of ultraviolet light (UV) for the orientation and flight behavior of the thrips, Ceratothripoides claratris, an important pest on tomato in the hot and humid tropics of South-East Asia. Four greenhouse types characterized by different combinations of UV absorbing or transmitting plastic films and nets on the roof and sidewalls, respectively, were used in these studies. In choice experiments C. claratris always preferred the environment with higher UV intensity. Furthermore natural thrips populations around the greenhouses were captured during the majority of control dates in lower numbers on sticky traps on the outer sidewalls of greenhouses clad with UV absorbing materials compared to UV transmitting ones. The immigration of thrips into the UV absorbing greenhouses was also impeded, as measured by sticky traps on the inner side walls. UV absorbing plastic roofs showed the most pronounced deterrent effect for thrips movement towards greenhouses, and the UV absorbing net effectively reduced thrips numbers crossing the net barrier into the greenhouse. A simple extension of UV absorbing plastic roof around conventional greenhouses clad with UV transmitting plastic and net reduced thrips capture rates inside the greenhouse up to 77  % when thrips was released at 1 m distance from the net walls. These results are discussed in the context of wavelength dependent insect vision and the dilemma of tropical greenhouse constructions, i.e. physical pest exclusion vs. appropriate ventilation to assure a conducive microclimate for plant growth.

M.B. Hossain & H.-M. Poehling, (2009)
A comparative study of residual effects of Azadirachtin, Spinosad and Avermectin on Liriomyza sativae (Dip.: Agromyzidae) on tomatoes.
International Journal of Pest Management (accepted January 2009)


ABSTRACT
The toxicities of 1, 5, 10 and 14 day old residues of azadirachtin (5 and 10 ml/lw), spinosad (2 and 4 ml/lw) and avermectin (2 and 4 ml/lw) on tomato plants was evaluated against foliage-inhabiting life stages of L. sativae Blanchard in air-conditioned rearing rooms and greenhouses in central Thailand (Bangkok). Azadirachtin and spinosad caused no deterrent or ovicidal effects and the hatching rates of eggs were not different from control (water) treatments. Irrespective of applied dosage, avermectin severely reduced egg deposition and affected embryonic development. All three pesticides severely affected the survival of immature stages (i.e. L1, L2 and L3) of L. sativae, with mortality rates up to 100% for fresh (one day old) residues and adult eclosion completely stopped. Spinosad and avermectin had a longer persistency (up to 14 days) both under laboratory and greenhouse conditions compared to azadirachtin, the activity of which decreased significantly with residual age and especially under greenhouse conditions.

M.B. Hossain, H.-M. Poehling, G. Thöming & C. Borgemeister (in press)
Effects of soil application of neem (NeemAzal®-U) on different life stages of Liriomyza sativae (Diptera: Agromyzidae) on tomato in the humid tropics
Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection, 115 (1)


ABSTRACT
NeemAzal®-U, a formulation containing 17% azadirachtin developed for soil treatments, was tested in air conditioned laboratories and net greenhouses in Thailand to control Liriomyza sativae Blanchard (Diptera: Agromyzidae) on tomatoes (Lycopersicon esculentum). The substrates of potted tomato plants were drenched with set volumes of neem solutions of altered concentrations. All tested neem concentrations had very low effects on oviposition and egg hatching. Strong systemic effects however were recorded in the larval stages attaining mortalities up to 100% when high dose drenching solutions containing 3 g NeemAzal®-U l–1 water equivalent to 0.5 g l–1 azadirachtin A were implemented. First instar larvae were found to be most susceptible to all dosages tested. Activity of NeemAzal®-U was persistent since application of even seven days before infestation resulted in mortalities extending between 40 to 70%. Leafminer late 3rd instar surviving on treated plants and moving as so called prepupa to pupate in treated soils endured a very high mortality during pupal stage ensuing in few adult emergences even when the lowest NeemAzal®-U concentration of 0.75 g l–1 water was used. The direct effects of soil treatment were elucidated by rearing leafminers on untreated plants but treating the substrate used for pupal development. Significant mortalities were only obtained when soil treatment was performed immediately before prepupa moved to the soil.

Cheerapha Panyasiri, Tipvadee Attathom and Hans-Michael Poehling (2007)
Pathogenicity of entomopathogenic fungi - potential candidates to control insect pests on tomato under protected cultivation in Thailand
Journal of Plant Diseases and Plant Protection, 114 (6), 278–287


ABSTRACT
Thirty-three isolates of entomopathogenic fungi were bioassayed to determine their efficacy against thrips (Ceratothripoides claratris), mealybug (Pseudococcus cryptus) and whitefly (Bemisia tabaci), the most destructive insect pests of tomatoes cultivated in netted greenhouses in Thailand. Most effective fungi against thrips proved to be Paecilomyces fumosoroseus (BCC7058, FWA3 and FWA5), against mealybug Metarhizium anisopliae (KKU2) and against whitefly P. fumosoroseus (FWA3) and Fusarium solani (FWA1). The infection process of the fungi was visualized using a scanning electron microscope. White-rice, brown rice, broken-milled rice, corn and sorghum grains were evaluated for their capability to serve as solid substrate for fungus mass production. Results indicated that white-rice and broken-milled rice accounted for the highest conidial yield. Maximum conidial yield on most of the substrates could be achieved with 10 days incubation time. With most effective isolates from bioassays, pest-infested tomato plants were sprayed in insect screen cages to evaluate the potential as bio-insecticide in on-plant trials and to determine effective dose rates for spray application in greenhouses. The LC50 of P. fumosoroseus (FWA3) against C. claratris and B. tabaci were 9.51×104 conidia/ml and 9.41×104 conidia/ml respectively and the LC50 of M. anisopliae (KKU2) against P. cryptus was 2.35×106 conidia/ml. These two isolates provide high potential as biocontrol agents for IPM approaches for the most important insect pests in tropical greenhouses.

P.Kumar and H.-M. Poehling (2007)
Effects of Azadirachtin, Abamectin, and Spinosad on Sweetpotato Whitefly (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) on Tomato Plants Under Laboratory and Greenhouse Conditions in the Humid Tropics
J. Econ. Entomol. 100(2): 411-420


ABSTRACT
Direct and residual toxicity of NeemAzal-T/S (azadirachtin), Success (spinosad), and abamectin was tested against different life stages of sweetpotato whitefly, Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) (Homoptera:Aleyrodidae),under air-conditioned laboratory conditions and in a tropical net greenhouse. NeemAzal-T/S and abamectin deterred the settling of adults on tomato, Lycopersicon esculentum Mill (Solanaceae), plants and consequently reduced egg deposition. No such effect was detected for Success. All three pesticides influenced egg hatch. Effects of NeemAzal-T/S were significantly altered if applied to different-aged eggs (1, 3, and 5 d old). In contrast,abamectin-treated eggs failed to hatch at any given age class. All three products caused heavy mortality of the three nymphal stages of B.tabaci, with the first in stars being most susceptible. Abamectin-treated nymphs died within 24 h postapplication. In contrast, 100% nymphal mortality with NeemAzal-T/S and Success was reached 6-9 d postapplication. Abamectin caused 100% immature mortality at all residue ages (1, 5, 10, and 15 d)in the laboratory and greenhouse as well. Persistence of Success was comparably high in the laboratory, but in the greenhouse a faster decline of activity was evident by increased egg deposition, egg hatch, and reduced rates of immature mortality. Toxicity of NeemAzal-T/S however gradually declined under greenhouse conditions with time (5 d) postapplication. The findings are discussed within the context of integrated management of whitefly under protected cultivation in the humid tropics.

Prabhat Kumar and H.-M. Poehling (2006)
Persistence of soil and foliar azadirachtin treatments to controlsweetpotato whitefly Bemisia tabaci Gennadius (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) on tomatoes under controlled (laboratory) and field (netted greenhouse) conditions in the humid tropics
J Pest Sci (2006) 79: 189–199


ABSTRACT
Persistence of neem-based products against sweetpotato whitefly Bemisia tabaci Gennadius (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) was tested in air conditioned rearing rooms and tropical netted greenhouses (GHs). Two commercial neem products, NeemAzal®-T/S (1% azadirachtin) and NeemAzal®-U (17% azadirachtin), were used. Foliar application, under room conditions at dose-rates of 7 and 10 ml NeemAzal®-T/S, induced an immature mortality of 32 and 44%, respectively, whereas 7 days post-application, under GH conditions, mortality rates declined to 5 and 7%, respectively. This result indicated rapid dissipation of the active ingredients. However, systemic application by soil drenching resulted in more stable eVects under both laboratory and GH conditions. After soil drenching with solutions of 3.0 g NeemAzal®- U until 7-day, immature mortality declined from 88% for the Wrst day to almost half (45%) by day-7 in the GH, and from 90% on Wrst day to 64% by day-7 under laboratory condition. Similar response trends for B. tabaci were obtained for other parameters such as adult colonisation, egg deposition, and egg hatch. The loss of eYciency of the neem products was clearly related to dose-rate, methods of application, and environment (temperature and UV). Soil application is therefore, a convenient approach to achieve high eYciency and persistence with neem products under the conditions in tropical GH environments for whitefly management.

Thoeming, G. and H.-M. Poehling (2006)
Soil application of different neem products to control Ceratothripoides claratris (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) on tomatoes grown under protected cultivation in the humid tropics (Thailand)
International Journal of Pest Management, 52 (3): 239-248


ABSTRACT
Ceratothripoides claratris (Shumsher) is an important pest in the tropics, damaging a wide range of crops. Therefore, the effects of soil-applied neem products on C. claratris were investigated on tomatoes (Lycopersicon esculentum) cultivated under tropical conditions in greenhouses in Thailand. NeemAzal-U (NA-U) soil applications resulted in strong systemic effects against C. claratris on young tomato plants when high azadirachtin (AZA) concentrations (400 mg AZA/L) were repeatedly applied. Different application schedules (every second week, weekly, twice a week) as well as organic matter content of typical growing substrates resulted in no significant influence on thrips control. However, plant age did have an influence. The younger the plants were the stronger were the effects after neem soil treatments. A delayed soil application with AZA resulted in increasing thrips population numbers. Of the different Neem products tested, Thai Neem Oil 111 showed the lowest efficiency compared to NA-U and Thai Neem Pellet 222.

P.Kumar and H.-M. Poehling (2006)
UV-blocking Plastic Films and Nets Influence Vectors and Virus Transmission on Greenhouse Tomatoes in the Humid Tropics
Environ. Entomol. 35(4): 1069-1082
References Cited (PDF)


ABSTRACT
We studied the effect of UV-blocked greenhouses made from netting and plastics on the movement and pest status of three important pest of tomatoes: whitefly (Bemisia tabaci), thrips (Ceratothripoides claratris), and aphid (Aphis gossypii). Under UV-blocked greenhouses, fewer whiteflies, aphids, and thrips entered the greenhouse compared with the ones having more UV intensity. Similarly, signifcantly fewer alate aphids and adult B. tabaci/leaf were counted in greenhouses with low UV intensity. Although thrips were the most abundant pest, they also were signifcantly less abundant in greenhouses with lower UV intensity. Consequently, significantly lower levels of leaf infestation were recorded under these greenhouse conditions. During open gates experiments, virus infection levels reached 96 -100% underUVnonblocking greenhouses compared with 6-10% infection levels in greenhouses whereUVirradiation was blocked. In addition, the appearance of virus symptoms was considerably delayed under greenhouses made from the UV-blocking roof material, although the majority of the plants tested positive for the tospovirus, capsicum chlorosis virus (CaCV; AIT isolate). The results are discussed in context of improved management of sucking insect pests of tomatoes inthe humid tropics.

M.B. Hossain and H.-M. Poehling (2006)
Effects of a Neem-based Insecticide on Different Immature Life Stages of the Leafminer Liriomyza sativae on Tomato
Phytoparasitica 34(4):360-369
References Cited (PDF)

ABSTRACT
The effects of the commercially available neem insecticide NeemAzal-T/S ® (neem) (1% azadirachtin) on Liriomyza sativae (Diptera: Agromyzidae) were studied on tomato in Bangkok, Thailand. Neem emulsions were sprayed on the aerial plant parts at five concentrations (from 0.001% to 0.010% a.i.); different aged residues (0, 1, 3, 5, and 7 days) were tested, in both controlled environment rooms and in greenhouses. Irrespective of the residual age of the application, no signifcant effects on oviposition or egg hatch were detected. However, neem drastically increased larval mortality at the higher concentrations tested. The L1 and L2 larvae were most susceptible. Irrespective of concentration, larval mortality or inhibition of adult eclosion decreased much faster in greenhouses than in controlled environments with artifcial light. Nevertheless, our results suggest that neem has potential to control L. sativae in netted greenhouses.

M. Babul Hossain and H.-M. Poehling (2006)
Non-target effects of three biorationale insecticides on two endolarval parasitoids of Liriomyza sativae (Dipt., Agromyzidae)
J. Appl. Entomol. 130(6-7), 360-367

ABSTRACT
Side effects of two azadirachtin formulations [NeemAzal-U (17% azadirachtin) and NeemAzal®-T/S (1% azadirachtin)] and two biorationale pesticides - Success® (Spinosad) and Abamectin (Avermectin) on two endoparasitoids Opius (Opiothorax) chromatomyiae and Neochrysocharis formosa of Liriomyza sativae were investigated under laboratory conditions. The eggs of O. chromatomyiae, and the eggs, larvae and pupae of N.formosa within the host or within the plant/host complex were exposed to NeemAzal, Success and Abamectin at different dose rates. Adult emergence of O. chromatomyiae from parasitized L. sativae in NeemAzal-U (0.75, 1.5, 2.25 and 3 g/l water) drenched soil was only slightly lower than from untreated control hosts. In contrast, adult emergence of unparasitized L. sativae was almost completely inhibited by NeemAzal-U, indicating a high, direct toxicity. Development of O. chromatomyiae within L3 of L. sativae was very much affected from topical applications of NeemAzal®-T/S, Success® and Abamectin at particular dose rates. Spraying of tomato leaves with NeemAzal®-T/S revealed no detrimental effect on the adult emergence of N. formosa developing in mining L2 of L. sativae. This was in contrast to Success® and Abamectin which strongly affected N. formosa adult emergence when applied at different immature developmental stages of N. formosa.

Babul Hossain (2006).
Effects of Azadirachtin and the natural pesticides Spinosad and Avermectin on the leafminer Liriomyza sativae (Diptera: Agromyzidae) and its parasitoids on tomatoes under protected cultivation in the humid tropics
Dissertation, University of Hannover
Download the full thesis as PDF

SUMMARY
Among the economic important Liriomyza spp., Liriomyza sativae causes substantial damage to tomatoes for instance infestation strongly reduces the photosynthetic activities resulting in high yield losses. The studies were conducted to investigate the effects of biopesticides (NeemAzal®-U and NeemAzal®-T/S) and biorational pesticides (Spinosad and Abamectin) on L. sativae and its two parasitoids, Opius (Opiothorax) chromatomyiae and Neochrysocharis formosa both under laboratory and greenhouse conditions. All tested NeemAzal®-U (17% Azadirachtin) concentrations applied as solutions to the substrate of potted tomatoes had very low effects on oviposition and egg hatch. However, strong systemic effects were observed in different larval stages attaining mortalities up to 100% when a high dosage of soil drenching solution (3.0 g NeemAzal®-U/lw) was implemented. The early instar (L1) larvae were found to be most susceptible to all dosages tested. Significant efficacy of NeemAzal®-U could be measured up to one week post-application. Leafminer prepupae moving to pupate in treated soil suffered from a very high mortality which resulted in only very few adults emerging even when the lowest NeemAzal®-U concentration of 0.75 g/lw was used. The direct effects of soil treatment were elucidated with high mortality values subsequent to instant soil treatment of prepupae and pupae reared on untreated plants. NeemAzal®-T/S (1% Azadirachtin) was applied on aerial plants parts with five increasing concentrations (1 ml, 3 ml, 5 ml, 7 ml and 10 ml/lw), and different ages of residues. Irrespective of the residual age of the topical application, no significant effects of NeemAzal®-T/S was found on oviposition and egg hatch. However, NeemAzal®-T/S strongly induced immature mortality at higher dosage rates. The L1 and L2 larvae were found to be most susceptible. The larval mortality reached up 100% and completely inhibited adult eclosion. Irrespective of NeemAzal®-T/S concentrations its efficiency in terms of induced larval mortality or inhibition of adult eclosion decreased much faster in greenhouses than in an air conditioned environment. Nevertheless, the results suggest that NeemAzal®-T/S applied topically has a high potential to control L. sativae in netted greenhouses in the humid tropics.
In comparative study, NeemAzal®-T/S and Success® caused no effects on oviposition and egg hatch compared to untreated control (water treatment). Irrespective of tested dosages, Abamectin strongly reduced egg deposition and severely affected embryonic development. All three pesticides severely affected the survival of immature stages (i.e. L1, L2 and L3) of L. sativae, with mortality up to 100% for fresh (one day old) residues and adult eclosions were completely stopped. Success® and Abamectin had a longer persistency (up to 14 days) both under laboratory and greenhouse conditions compared to NeemAzal®-T/S, the activity of which decreased significantly with residual age under greenhouse conditions.
The successes of adult emergence of O. chromatomyiae from all concentrations of NeemAzal®-U drenched soil against parasitized larvae/prepupae of L. Sativae were slightly affected compared to untreated control. In contrast, adult emergence of L. sativae encountering NeemAzal®-U only directly from drenched soil in the prepupal stage which has not been exposed to the parasitoids was strongly reduced. However, adult emergence of O. chromatomyiae in L3 of L. sativae was strongly affected from topical application of NeemAzal®-T/S, Success® and Abamectin. In a further study, NeemAzal®-T/S revealed no detrimental effect on the adult emergence of N. Formosa developed in L2 of L. sativae within leafminer mines in the leaves. In contrast, Success® and Abamectin strongly reduced N. formosa emergence when applied at different immature developmental stages of N. formosa.

Prabhat Kumar (2006).
Management of Sweetpotato Whitefly Bemisia tabaci Gennadius (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) on tomato using biorational pesticides (Neem, Abamectin and Spinosad) and UV-absorbing nets and films as greenhouse cover in the humid tropics
Dissertation, University of Hannover
Download the full thesis as PDF

SUMMARY
The sweetpotato (Whitefly, WF) Bemisia tabaci Gennadius (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae) originates from tropical and subtropical regions, now having a worldwide distribution as a serious pest of open field vegetable production (Tropics, Sub-tropics and Mediterranean regions) and crops grown under protected cultivation. The short and multiple life cycles with high reproduction rates under tropical conditions, fast selection of resistant biotypes to different classes of insecticides including organophosphates, pyrethroids, cyclodiens and even first, second generation neurotoxin nicotinoids, and even growth regulators are major control constraints. In addition, the waxy shelters protecting the immobile larval and pupal WF stages, high immigration and generation time, wide range of hosts (over 600 plant species) are characteristics that make its control extremely difficult.
Subject of the present studies were exploring the potential of the botanical pesticides, neem using its various application methods and concentrations to control WF and evaluating its persistency compared to so-called bio-rational natural pesticides like spinosad and abamectin. In addition, physical control strategy by using a combination of UV-blocking nets and plastics were explored to learn their potential to manipulate the immigration behavior (entry) of WF and other small sucking insect-pest of tomatoes like thrips and aphids taking into consideration also the thrips related spread of a tospovirus.
In first series of experiments, neem was tested using three different treatment methods (seed, soil and foliar) and two different commercial neem products (NeemAzal® T/S 1% Azadirachtin and NeemAzal® U 17% Azadirachtin) against WF on tomato plants. Studies were conducted in cages in air conditioned cultivation rooms. All three methods of neem treatments resulted in reduced colonization and oviposition by WF. Overall oviposition intensity was significantly reduced by the treatment of tomato seeds (261 eggs in control compared to 147 eggs at a dose-rate of 3.0g/l of NeemAzal® U) but an even higher reduction was achieved through soil drenching (345 egg in control compared to 90 eggs at 3.0g/l of NeemAzal® U) and foliar spraying (286 eggs in control compared to 53 eggs at 10 ml/l of NeemAzal®) TS.In contrast, in soil and foliar treatment fecundity per female increased at highest tested concentrations (from 19 eggs/female in blank treatments to 28 eggs per female at 3.0 g/l NeemAzal® U and from 15 eggs/female to 22 at NeemAzal® TS at 10 ml/l in foliar treatment). Reduced egg hatch could be observed only at high neem concentrations; 62 and 51% of deposited eggs hatched at highest doserates of NeemAzal®U at 3.0 g/l in case of seed and soil drenching treatments respectively; whereas only 43% of deposited eggs hatched in case of foliar treatments at highest dose-rates of 10 ml/l using NeemAzal® T/S. Seed (35%), foliar (93%) and soil treatments (91%) caused a significantly higher mortality of immatures and reduced number of hatching adults compared to control plants treated with a blank formulation or water. The mortality amongst immatures increased in relation to azadirachtin concentrations. Concerning susceptibility of different developmental stages, young larvae showed the most sensitive reaction. The most efficient treatment was foliar treatment, which achieved 100 % mortality for all three larval stages at high concentrations (10.0 ml/l of NeemAzal® T/S) compared to 78-87% mortality with soil treatment (at 3.0g/l of NeemAzal® U).
To further explore the possibilities of developing synergy with locally available parasitoids of WF, persistence of foliar and systemic application of azadirachtin was tested for 7 days (1,3,5 and 7) in air conditioned rearing rooms and tropical netted greenhouses using the same two products described for the first experiments. Foliar application induced under closed room conditions at doserates of 7 and 10 ml NeemAzalTS/l immature mortality of 32 and 44 % respectively 7-days post application, where as under greenhouse conditions these rates declined to 5 and 7 % during the same period indicating rapid dissipation of active ingredient. However, systemic application resulted in more stable effects under both laboratory and greenhouse conditions. After soil drenching with solutions of 3.0 g NeemAzalU/l until 7-d, immature mortality declined from 88% for the first day to almost half (45%) on 7-d. However in case of laboratory, it was 90% on first day and declined to 64% on 7-d post application. Similar trends of responses of the B. tabaci were obtained for other parameters like adult colonization, egg deposition and egg hatch. The loss of efficiency of the neem products was clearly related to the dose-rate, methods of application and environment (temperature and UV).
Soil application is therefore a convenient approach to achieve high efficiency and persistence with neem products under the critical conditions in tropical greenhouse environments. In third experiments, direct and residual toxicity of NeemAzal TS (azadirachtin), spinosad (Spinosyne) and abamectin (Avamectin) were tested against different life stages of WF under laboratory conditions and in a tropical net greenhouse. NeemAzal TS and abamectin deterred the settling of adults on the plant and consequently reduced egg deposition. No such effect was detected for spinosad. All three pesticides influenced egg hatch. Effects of NeemAzal TS were significantly altered if applied to different aged eggs (1, 3, and 5-d old). In contrast, abamectin treated eggs failed to hatch at any given age-class. Moreover, spinosad and NeemAzal TS influenced egg hatch in a concentration dependent manner. All three products caused heavy mortality of all three larval stages of B. tabaci, where the first instar larvae was found to be most susceptible compared to other two larval stages. Larval mortalities of 100% were achieved with NeemAzal TS at twice the recommend dose-rate (10ml/l) and at all tested concentrations of abamectin and spinosad. The daily mortality rates were highest for abamectin, all treated larvae at every larval stage died within 24 h post application. In contrast, 100% larval mortality in case of NeemAzalTS and spinosad was reached 6-9 days post application. The daily mortality rates were clearly concentration dependent. Abamectin caused 100% immature mortality at all residue ages (1, 5, 10 and 15-d) in the laboratory and greenhouse as well. Persistence of spinosad was comparable high in the laboratory but in the greenhouse a faster decline of activity was evident by increased egg deposition, egg hatch and reduced rates of immature mortality. Toxicity of NeemAzalTS however strongly declined under greenhouse conditions with time (5-d) post application.
The last series of experiments explored the possibility of integrating Uvblocking nets and plastics to develop appropriate physical control strategies for WF. The studies were conducted to investigate the effect of ultraviolet blocked greenhouses made from combination of net and plastics on the immigration of three important pest of tomatoes; WF (Bemisia tabaci), thrips (Ceratothripoides claratris), and aphid (Aphis gossypii) and occurrences of viruses e.g. tospovirus. Fewer WF, aphids and thrips immigrated and consequently were trapped either, when gates kept open whole day (complete ventilation) or partially open from 6.00 – 10.00 (partial ventilation) in greenhouses made from the combination of UV-blocking nets and plastics compared to non UV-blocking nets and plastic greenhouse. Similarly, significantly less number of alate aphids and adult B. tabaci/leaf were counted within greenhouses with low intensity of the UV over those with more UV light intensity. Thrips were the most occurring pests, that too were recorded significantly less under GH with lower UV-intensity and consequently significantly lower levels of leaf damage were recorded under these greenhouses. During, open gates experiments (complete ventilation), a 96-100% virus infestation was recorded under non UV-blocking greenhouses compared to 6-10% under UV-blocking greenhouses, having majority of the plants tested positive for the tospovirus, CaCV (isolate AIT). The virus spreads were remarkably delayed for several days under greenhouses with lower UV light. These results suggests that greenhouses made from the combination of the UV-blocking nets and plastics have a significant influence on the both the immigration and virus spread vectored by some of these insects. The results are discussed in context of improved management of sucking insect-pests of tomatoes in the humid tropics under protected cultivation.

Gunda Thöming (2005).
Soil application of neem products in IPM:
Controlling Frankliniella occidentalis and Ceratothripoides claratris (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) in vegetable crops
Dissertation, University of Hannover
Download the full thesis as PDF

SUMMARY
The extract of the neem tree Azadirachta indica (Meliaceae) with its insecticidal and ecological properties has been classified as one of the most important bioactive compounds of plants for integrated pest management. Currently, neem preparations have been mainly applied as spray treatment on the crop canopy with varying levels of success in pest control. The potential of neem extract applications to the soil and the use of the systemic properties of the botanical ingredients in controlling thrips was investigated in this study.

Thrips such as Frankliniella occidentalis and Ceratothripoides claratris (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) are important pests causing high economic damage in a wide range of crops worldwide. Their characteristic life cycle with plant- and soil-dwelling stages, cryptic feeding behaviour, short generation time and high mobility led to a fast development of resistances against insecticides, which makes thrips control very difficult.

The presented studies were carried out in protected vegetable cultivation in temperate zone in Germany and in the tropics in Thailand. Different thrips species, vegetable crops and environmental conditions in general were used to acquire that way a more complex analysis on the potential use of soil-applied neem ingredients in pest control.

To study the systemic effects of active neem ingredients the substrate of bean plants was treated with NeemAzal-U (NA-U) solutions (17% azadirachtin (AZA)). Afterwards the translocation and persistence of AZA, 3-tigloyl-azadirachtol, salanin and nimbin and the effects on F. occidentalis were studied. Residues of the active components from substrates with different contents of organic matter (pure culture substrate (CS), CS-sand mixture) and from various plant parts were quantified by HPLC-MS. The dissipation trend of AZA and 3-tigloyl-azadirachtol was similar within the same substrates. A slower decline of both active ingredients was measured with CS versus CS-sand mixture. The residue analyses from bean plants showed that only small proportions of the initial amount of the active ingredients applied to the substrate were measured in the plant (0.3% – 8.8%). Variable amounts of residues of the active components in relation to plant parts and time of analysis indicated a different translocation pattern of active ingredients. Mortality of F. occidentalis after NA-U soil applications reached up to 95% on CS-sand mixture compared to 86% in CS.

In the second part, the efficacy of soil treatments using AZA in combination with the two different predatory mite species Amblyseius cucumeris (Acari: Phytoseiidae) and Hypoaspis aculeifer (Acari: Laelapidae) to control F. occidentalis was tested. The study also looked at side effects on the antagonists and was conducted in the laboratory and greenhouses using Phaseolus vulgaris. The release of a single predatory mite species resulted in unreliable and varying reductions of thrips numbers. Antagonist combinations improved efficiencies ranging from 54% to 85%. NA-U caused mortalities from 70% to 98% after soil application. A combination of AZA with predatory mites enhanced not only consistency in thrips control but also resulted in efficacies up to 99%. No detrimental effects of NA-U on the survival of both predators were recorded. However, a significant reduction in population development of H. aculeifer was noted.

Moreover, the effects of soil-applied neem products on C. claratris were investigated on Lycopersicon esculentum cultivated under tropical conditions in greenhouses in Thailand. NA-U soil applications demonstrated strong systemic effects against C. claratris. More than 85% mortality on young tomato plants was achieved when high AZA concentrations were repeatedly applied. Different application schedules as well as organic matter content of typical growing substrates resulted in no significant influence on thrips control. However, plant age did have an influence on the outcome. The younger the plants the stronger were the effects after neem soil treatments. A delayed soil application with AZA resulted in increasing thrips populations. Of the different Neem products tested Thai Neem Oil 111 showed the lowest efficiency compared to NA-U and Thai Neem Pellet 222.

Studies on three different neem treatment methods (seed, soil and foliar) and two different commercial neem products (NeemAzal T/S 1% azadirachtin and NeemAzalU 17% azadirachtin) against sweetpotato white fly (WF) Bemisia tabaci Gennadius (Hom., Aleyrodidae) on tomato plants were conducted in cages in air-conditioned cultivation rooms. All three methods of neem treatments resulted in reduced colonization and oviposition. Overall oviposition intensity was significantly reduced (44%) by the treatment of tomato seeds but an even higher reduction (74%) was achieved through soil drenching both with 3.0 g/l NeemAzalU and foliar spraying (82%) with 10 ml/l of NeemAzal TS compared with control treatments. In contrast, soil and foliar treatment increased fecundity per female up to 33% and 32%, respectively, at the highest tested concentrations. Reduced egg hatch could be observed only at high neem concentrations; 62% and 51% of deposited eggs hatched at the highest dose rates of NeemAzalU in case of seed and foliar treatments, respectively; whereas only 43% of deposited eggs hatched in case of foliar treatments at highest dose rates of NeemAzal T/S. Seed (35%), foliar (93%) and soil treatments (91%) caused high mortality rates of immatures and reduced number of hatching adults compared with control plants treated with a blank formulation or water. The mortality among immatures increased in relation to azadirachtin concentrations. Concerning susceptibility of different developmental stages, young larvae were the most sensitive. Foliar treatment was the most effcient, with 100% mortality for all three larval stages at high concentrations (10 ml/l of NeemAzal T/S) compared with 78 - 87% mortality with soil treatment (at 3.0 g/l NeemAzalU). The findings are discussed in the context of integrated control of WF in protected cultivation environments in the humid tropics.

P. Kumar, H.-M. Poehling and C. Borgemeister (2005).
Effects of different application methods of azadirachtin against sweetpotato whitefly Bemisia tabaci Gennadius (Hom., Aleyrodidae) on tomato plants
J. Appl. Entomol., 2005, Vol. 129 (9/10), 489-497.

ABSTRACT
Studies on three different neem treatment methods (seed, soil and foliar) and two different commercial neem products (NeemAzal T/S 1% azadirachtin and NeemAzalU 17% azadirachtin) against sweetpotato white fly (WF) Bemisia tabaci Gennadius (Hom., Aleyrodidae) on tomato plants were conducted in cages in air-conditioned cultivation rooms. All three methods of neem treatments resulted in reduced colonization and oviposition. Overall oviposition intensity was significantly reduced (44%) by the treatment of tomato seeds but an even higher reduction (74%) was achieved through soil drenching both with 3.0 g/l NeemAzalU and foliar spraying (82%) with 10 ml/l of NeemAzal TS compared with control treatments. In contrast, soil and foliar treatment increased fecundity per female up to 33% and 32%, respectively, at the highest tested concentrations. Reduced egg hatch could be observed only at high neem concentrations; 62% and 51% of deposited eggs hatched at the highest dose rates of NeemAzalU in case of seed and foliar treatments, respectively; whereas only 43% of deposited eggs hatched in case of foliar treatments at highest dose rates of NeemAzal T/S. Seed (35%), foliar (93%) and soil treatments (91%) caused high mortality rates of immatures and reduced number of hatching adults compared with control plants treated with a blank formulation or water. The mortality among immatures increased in relation to azadirachtin concentrations. Concerning susceptibility of different developmental stages, young larvae were the most sensitive. Foliar treatment was the most effcient, with 100% mortality for all three larval stages at high concentrations (10 ml/l of NeemAzal T/S) compared with 78 - 87% mortality with soil treatment (at 3.0 g/l NeemAzalU). The findings are discussed in the context of integrated control of WF in protected cultivation environments in the humid tropics.

URBANUS N. MUTWIWA, CHRISTIAN BORGEMEISTER, BURKHARD VON ELSNER AND HANS-JUERGEN TANTAU (2005).
Effects of UV-Absorbing Plastic Films on Greenhouse Whitefly (Homoptera: Aleyrodidae)
Journal of Economic Entomology, 2005, 98(4): 1221-1228.

ABSTRACT
Studies were conducted to investigate the effects of ultraviolet (UV)-absorbing plastic films on the orientation and distribution behavior of the greenhouse whitefly, Trialeurodes vaporariorum (Westwood). In field experiments, small tunnels were constructed and covered with either an UV-transmitting (Thermilux) or UV-absorbing (K-Rose) plastic film. Results show that significantly more whiteflies were recorded in the tunnels with high compared with those with low UV intensities. Moreover, whitefly penetration and dispersion were less inside the UV-deficient tunnels. These results suggest that the type of plastic film used for greenhouse covers may have a significant influence on both the initial immigration and distribution of T. vaporariorum into greenhouses. The possibilities of using UV-absorbing plastic films for whitefly integrated pest management in greenhouses are discussed.

W. T. S. D. Premachandra, C. Borgemeister, E. Maiss, D. Knierim, and H.-M. Poehling (2005).
Ceratothripoides claratris, a New Vector of a Capsicum chlorosis virus Isolate Infecting Tomato in Thailand
Phytopathology, 2005, Vol. 95, No. 6, 659-663.

ABSTRACT
Ceratothripoides claratris, the predominant thrips species on tomato in Thailand, was tested for vector competence and efficiency to transmit Capsicum chlorosis virus (CaCV) (isolate AIT) to tomato. The efficiency of adult-stage transmission was influenced by the larval stage at which virus was acquired. Adult C. claratris showed 69% transmission efficiency after acquiring the virus as freshly emerged (<1 h) first-instar larvae. However, when just molted (<1 h) second-instar larvae acquired the virus, the percentage of adult transmitters significantly decreased (48%). Transmission efficiency of up to 47% was detected with second-instar larvae of C. claratris which had acquired the virus as freshly emerged first-instar larvae. Transmission efficiency did not significantly differ between adult males and females, irrespective of the larval stage at which the virus was acquired. Highest transmission efficiency for CaCV was recorded in adult C. claratris derived from second-instar larvae collected from infected tomato plants in a greenhouse. Lowest transmission efficiency was observed in adults directly collected from infected tomato plants in the greenhouse. The spread of CaCV on tomato plants in greenhouses showed a close association with thrips infestations.

DAMMINI W.T.S. PREMACHANDRA, CHRISTIAN BORGEMEISTER AND HANS-MICHAEL POEHLING (2005).
Effects of Neem and Spinosad on Ceratothripoides claratris (Thysanoptera: Thripidae), an Important Vegetable Pest in Thailand, Under Laboratory and Greenhouse Conditions
Journal of Economic Entomology, 2005, 98(2): 438-448.

ABSTRACT
Toxicity of three biopesticides, i.e., two neem products and spinosad, was determined on foliage-dwelling life stages of Ceratothripoides claratris (Shumsher) (Thysanoptera: Thripidae), a major thrips pest on tomatoes, Lycopersicon spp., in central Thailand. Direct and residual contact toxicities of NeemAzal-TS (1% azadirachtin) and systemic activity of NeemAzal-MD 5 (5% azadirachtin) affected the survival of first larval stage (L1) in a concentration-dependent manner. However, neither second larval stage (L2) nor adult survival was influenced by both neem products. On the contrary, spinosad caused 100% mortality in both larval stages and adults of C. claratris regardless of the concentrations tested. No strong ovicidal effects were detected in three different age groups of eggs (i.e., 1, 2, and 3 d old) topically treated with both NeemAzal-TS and spinosad. Residual toxicity was highest with fresh residues of NeemAzal-TS compared with 1-, 3-, 5-, and 7-d-old residues and in general was higher under laboratory than greenhouse conditions. Irrespective of the age of the spray residues, spinosad always caused 100% mortality in larvae and adults. Strongest systemic effects were observed in L1 larvae 1 d after soil drenching with NeemAzal-MD 5 at the highest concentration tested. Foliar and soil applications of NeemAzal-TS and NeemAzal-MD 5, respectively, did not cause any oviposition deterrent effects.

W.T.S.D. Premachandra, C. Borgemeister, A. Chabi-Olaye and H.-M. Poehling (2004).
Influence of temperature on the development, reproduction and longevity of Ceratothripoides claratris (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) on tomatoes
Bulletin of Entomological Research, 2004, 94, 377-384.

ABSTRACT
Ceratothripoides claratris (Shumsher) is a serious pest attacking tomatoes in Thailand. Temperature-dependent development of C. claratris was studied at seven constant temperatures, i.e. 22, 25, 27, 30, 34, 35 and 40°C. Pre-adult survivorship was greatest (95%) at 25 and 30°C and shortest at 22°C. Egg-to-adult time decreased within the range of 20 to 30°C and at 34°C it started to increase. The lower thermal threshold for egg-to-adult development was estimated at 16 and 18°C by linear regression and the modified Logan model, respectively. The optimum temperature for egg-to-adult development was estimated at 32 - 33°C by the modified Logan model. The influence of temperature on reproduction and longevity of C. claratris was determined at 25, 30 and 35 and 40°C. Both inseminated and virgin females failed to reproduce at 40°C. Virgin females produced only male offspring, confirming arrhenotoky. The sex ratio of the offspring of fertilized females was strongly female-biased, except at 25°C. Mean total fecundity per female and mean daily total fecundity per female were highest for both virgin and inseminated females at 30°C. Female longevity was longest at 25°C and shortest at 40°C. Male longevity was longest at 30°C and shortest at 40°C. The net reproductive rate (R0) and intrinsic rate of natural increase (rm) was greatest at 30°C while, mean generation time (G) and the doubling time (t) were highest at 25°C. The finite rate of increase () was fairly constant (1.1 - 1.5 days) over the three temperatures tested. The pest potential of C. claratris for tropical Asia is discussed.

Dammini W.T.S. PREMACHANDRA, Christian BORGEMEISTER, Oliver BERNDT, Ralf-Udo EHLERS 2 and Hans-Michael POEHLING (2003).
Laboratory bioassays of virulence of entomopathogenic nematodes against soil-inhabiting stages of Frankliniella occidentalis Pergande (Thysanoptera: Thripidae)
Nematology, 2003, Vol. 5(4), 539-547.

ABSTRACT
The efficacy of entomopathogenic nematodes (EPN) was evaluated in a laboratory trial against soil-dwelling stages, late second instar larvae and pupal stages of western flower thrips (WFT), Frankliniella occidentalis Pergande. Among the six EPN strains assessed for the first time, Steinernema feltiae (Nemaplus®) and Heterorhabditis bacteriophora (HD01) caused 65 and 59% mortality, respectively. Steinernema carpocapsae (Agriotos) and S. arenarium (Anomali) caused moderate mortality (40-45%) while Steinernema spp. (Morocco) and H. bacteriophora (Nematop®) had little effect. In a dose response study with concentrations of 100, 400 and 800 infective juveniles (IJ) per cm2 soil of H. bacteriophora (HK3), S. feltiae (Nemaplus®) and H. bacteriophora (HD01), mortality increased only up to 400 IJ cm-2. The rate of infectivity of H. bacteriophora (HK3) and S. feltiae (Nemaplus®) indicated that both strains could survive at least 6 days in the soil and infect WFT immature stages.

Back to content